The Look of Vapes Has Changed. Here’s Why the Shift Has Experts Worried.
[ad_1]
Alexa Addison remembers what vapes looked like when she was in high school. The dominant e-cigarette was Juul, a slim, black rectangle with sharp corners that resembled a flash drive.
By the time Ms. Addison, 19, started college at the University of North Carolina Wilmington last year, the vape du jour had shifted. She saw many of her classmates brandishing Elf Bars, brightly colored e-cigarettes that looked like ombré AirPods cases, with gently sloped chimneys for inhalation.
She bought flavors like piña colada and strawberry-kiwi, and took pictures when the candy-colored gradients of the devices coordinated with her outfits. Soon she found herself going through an Elf Bar a week. (Each one contains as much nicotine as 590 cigarettes, according to one estimate.) Ms. Addison said that during her period of most intense use, her gums turned gray.
“They looked really pretty, honestly,” she said of the devices. “I just never had an interest in vaping until the pretty ones started being sold.”
About five years after Juul became many people’s mental image for the word “vape,” e-cigarettes are in the midst of another face-lift. The understated look associated with Juul has been edged out by the rounded, vivid designs of Elf Bars and other brands, whose color schemes often correspond with their flavors.
In interviews, young people compared the appearance of these disposable e-cigarettes to candy, pacifiers, lip gloss and soap. “They almost look like toys,” said Carter James, 23, a music producer who lives in Brooklyn and said he stopped using e-cigarettes this summer.
Some public health experts are concerned that the playful appearance of these devices — which is neatly in line with the maximalist aesthetic preferences of Gen Z — may offer appealing new cover for nicotine products. Doctors say nicotine is especially addictive for young people, and research suggests that teenage vapers risk both immediate and long-term lung damage.
In combination with candy- and fruit-inspired flavors — a major focus of anti-tobacco groups — alluring vape packaging could steer young people toward e-cigarettes, several experts said.
“If it looks glamorous and it looks appealing, that’s going to be the first driver that will bring a horse to water,” said Brian King, the chief of the Food and Drug Administration’s tobacco center. “The flavors then get them to drink. And the nicotine keeps them coming back for more.”
Joe Camel for Gen Z?
Susan Linn, a psychologist and lecturer in psychiatry at Harvard Medical School, said there was “no question” that the appearance of Elf Bars was geared to catch the eyes of adolescents or even children, who gravitate toward bright colors and rounded shapes.
She compared the juvenile look of Elf Bars to Joe Camel, the cartoon character retired by R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company after years of criticism that it was targeted to children. Decades later, e-cigarette companies also made visual appeals to young people: In 2018, the F.D.A. issued warnings to companies that sold nicotine products that looked like juice boxes.
“Tobacco companies use cartoons or brightly colored packaging in order to hook kids, to make kids think that this is benign, fun and harmless to them,” said Dr. Linn, who is also the author of “Consuming Kids,” a book about marketing to children.
About one in 10 high school students has used an e-cigarette in the past month, according to the National Youth Tobacco Survey, released this month. And while e-cigarette use among teenagers has generally declined since 2019, flavored, disposable devices including Elf Bar have been ascendant.
Elf Bar, which is also sold under the names EBDesign and EBCreate, hit U.S. shelves in November 2021, according to The Associated Press. By this summer, it had become the leading e-cigarette brand among middle- and high-school students who vape, according to the survey. Visually similar products abound, including Flum Pebble, Juicy Bar, Air Bar Nex and Lost Mary.
The company that manufactures Elf Bar, IMiracle Shenzhen Technology, has argued that it is being unfairly targeted by the F.D.A. and that its products, which carry a stark, black-and-white label warning that nicotine is addictive, are geared toward adult consumers. Representatives for IMiracle did not respond to requests for comment for this article.
Still, some see the physical design of the devices as a clear appeal to the visual sensibility of Gen Z.
“I would certainly argue that modern vapes, especially Elf Bars, are targeted more toward young Gen Z and even Gen Alpha,” said Ben Varquez, the managing director of YMC, a youth-marketing agency that does not work with clients in the tobacco industry.
Today’s young customers are less drawn to tech-y minimalism than to vibrant color palettes and playful silhouettes that stand out on social media, he said. If Elf Bar was trying to design a product in line with Gen Z consumer tastes, he said, “they’ve absolutely nailed it.”
Some e-cigarettes are being packaged similarly to beauty, cosmetic and skin-care products that line the shelves at Sephora. Their pastel boxes are of a piece with upscale beverage brands like Kin Euphorics or the woozy gradients of Partiful, an event-invitation platform favored by Gen Z.
“It’s this small, round cutesy thing with super bright colors that looks really friendly,” said Taylor McGee, 26, a graphic designer in Brooklyn. “It’s positioned closer to these banal objects that aren’t bad for you.”
Elf Bar’s resemblance to more innocuous items can belie its contents, said Bonnie Halpern-Felsher, a professor of pediatrics at Stanford University who led the development of a tobacco-prevention curriculum. An emerging body of research suggests that teenagers become addicted to nicotine more easily than adults do, she said, and that some cases of heart disease, asthma and bronchitis may be connected to vaping.
And yet: “It looks like hand sanitizer,” she said.
The F.D.A. has greenlit some e-cigarettes in order to help adult smokers transition away from cigarettes. But it has banned the sale of most flavored vapes, citing the risks of their appeal to young people.
That sets them apart from the earliest e-cigarettes, which were clunky modular systems or simple white “cig-a-likes” that mimicked the appearance of real cigarettes.
Then came Juul, a sleek, dark rectangle created by two graduates of Stanford’s design school and released in 2015. Minimal and discreet, it enabled young people to covertly vape in class or their school bathrooms.
Juul became “the poster child for all the ways the vaping industry went wrong,” said Jamie Ducharme, the author of “Big Vape: The Incendiary Rise of Juul” and a health correspondent at Time magazine. The device’s distinctive design — once a selling point — became associated with “flouting regulation and kicking off a scandal.”
Ms. Ducharme speculated that newer e-cigarette companies probably wanted to distance themselves from the look of Juul. “I’m not sure they went in the correct direction,” she said.
‘You Want to Show It Off’
The bolder look of new, disposable e-cigarettes may correspond with a shift in some young people’s openness about vaping.
When Karely Alcantara, 21, began vaping in high school, most of her friends used Juuls, which were easily concealed from teachers and family members. Today Ms. Alcantara, now a student at the University of Maryland, sees people treating Elf Bars as ubiquitous accessories. She spots them at bars, in the cafeteria at her student center, and on TikTok and Instagram.
“Nobody’s trying to hide it anymore, because everybody vapes” Ms. Alcantara said. She said she stopped vaping last year with the help of a text-messaging program from Truth Initiative, a tobacco-control group. She is now a student ambassador for the initiative, a role for which she has received a stipend.
Many high schoolers who got hooked on Juul have aged into young adults with less oversight into their vaping habits, added Mr. James, the music producer. “The whole Juul wave was more about being discreet,” he said. “Now it’s like, you want to show it off.”
On a recent afternoon in October, Elf Bars were a highly visible accessory in the landscape of Lower Manhattan. Young people clutched them in the same fist as their phones or keys. A strawberry-mango Elf Bar sat on a table at an outdoor restaurant, next to its owner’s coffee. One man took a puff of a lemon-mint Elf Bar while waiting in line to enter the Supreme store.
They are just as visible online. On TikTok, videos tagged #elfbar have more than 2.5 billion views. A Reddit meme account Photoshops joke Elf Bar flavors like Tide Pods and Crab Rangoon. Videos that show people dressed up as Elf Bars for costume parties have amassed millions of views.
Not everyone is showing their Elf Bars off. Emma Longo, 22, a program coordinator at a church who lives in Fishers, Ind., said she started vaping because she thought it looked cool. The devices are always on hand among her friends; there is always a new color or flavor to try.
But seven years later, she hides the devices from family members. She relies on vaping to cope with stress, and worries about how it will affect her and her friends’ health in the long term.
Now, when she pictures a member of Gen Z, she said she pictures vaping. “It’s become a part of the culture,” she said. “Now that I’m really thinking about it and processing it, that’s kind of scary.”